No social sector employer begins an employment relationship hoping or expecting to dismiss someone for gross misconduct, but these situations do arise and knowing how to respond fairly and appropriately is essential.
So, an employee has done something that appears extremely serious. Perhaps there are concerns about misuse of organisational funds, threatening behaviour towards a colleague or a significant safeguarding failure.
Your immediate reaction may be that they cannot remain in the organisation.
However, even where the circumstances appear clear, employers should avoid jumping straight to dismissal. Gross misconduct can justify dismissal without notice, but an appropriate investigation and fair disciplinary procedure should still come first.
For charities, social enterprises and other not-for-profit organisations, these situations can be particularly challenging. Managers may be balancing concerns about employee wellbeing, beneficiary safety, limited resources and the organisation’s reputation.
Understanding how to dismiss an employee for gross misconduct helps employers make considered decisions whilst treating everyone involved fairly. In this blog, we explain what gross misconduct means, the procedure employers should follow and the common mistakes that can create unnecessary risk.
What is gross misconduct?
Gross misconduct is behaviour so serious, or with such serious consequences, that it may justify ending employment without notice or payment in lieu of notice.
This is known as summary dismissal.
However, describing behaviour as gross misconduct does not automatically make dismissal appropriate. Employers still need to establish what happened, consider the circumstances and decide whether dismissal is a reasonable response.
Examples of gross misconduct
Potential examples include:
- Theft or fraud
- Physical violence
- Serious bullying or harassment
- Gross negligence
- Serious insubordination
- Serious breaches of health and safety
- Serious breaches of confidentiality
- Deliberate damage to organisational property.
What amounts to gross misconduct can depend on the organisation, the employee’s responsibilities and the circumstances. Disciplinary policies will typically explain the types of behaviour the organisation considers sufficiently serious.
Within the social sector, concerns might involve misuse of charity funds, serious safeguarding failures or inappropriate disclosure of sensitive beneficiary information.
These situations require careful assessment. For example, an allegation that an employee deliberately shared confidential service user information needs a different investigation from an accidental disclosure involving unclear instructions or inadequate training.
The seriousness of the concern should guide a thorough investigation, whilst leaving the outcome open.
How to dismiss an employee for gross misconduct
A structured gross misconduct procedure will usually involve these ten steps:
- Check your disciplinary procedure.
- Consider whether suspension is necessary.
- Investigate the allegations.
- Decide whether there is a disciplinary case to answer.
- Invite the employee to a disciplinary hearing.
- Hold a fair hearing.
- Assess the evidence and circumstances.
- Decide on an appropriate sanction.
- Confirm the decision in writing.
- Offer the right of appeal.
1. Check your disciplinary procedure
Start by reviewing the employee’s contract, your disciplinary policy and any other relevant organisational policies. If you don’t have a disciplinary policy, you should follow the Acas Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures.
Identify who has authority to investigate, chair a hearing and make a decision. Where possible, different people should handle the investigation, disciplinary decision and any appeal. For smaller organisations, this can require some planning. If the Chief Executive witnessed the incident, for example, they may need to provide evidence rather than chair the hearing.
Consider whether an uninvolved senior manager, trustee or external professional could fulfil the appropriate role, in line with your governance arrangements and policies. Also review how comparable cases have been handled. Previous decisions provide useful context, although each case still needs individual consideration.
2. Consider whether suspension is necessary
Suspension should never be an automatic response to an allegation of gross misconduct. Consider whether allowing the employee to continue working would create a genuine risk to colleagues, beneficiaries, organisational resources or the investigation. Concerns might include interference with witnesses, destruction of evidence or continued access to sensitive systems. If so, suspension may be appropriate, but before deciding you should explore alternatives, such as temporarily changing duties, restricting access to particular systems or arranging work at another location.
Where suspension is necessary, explain the reasons and make clear that no disciplinary finding has been made. Keep it as brief as possible, review it regularly and provide a named contact for updates and support. If you have an Employee Assistance Programme (EAP) you may also want to signpost the employee to any support they can access through that offering.
The employee should continue receiving their usual pay and contractual benefits. Withholding pay during suspension can create legal risk, including where contractual wording appears to permit it.
3. Carry out a fair investigation
The purpose of a disciplinary investigation is to establish the facts.
An investigator should approach the allegations with an open mind, gathering evidence that both supports and challenges the concerns. Depending on the circumstances, this may involve reviewing documents, interviewing witnesses, examining relevant records and meeting with the employee to hear their account.
Keep clear records of the evidence considered, any inconsistencies and the reasons for the investigation’s conclusions.
Work promptly, whilst allowing enough time for a thorough and balanced assessment.
In a social sector organisation, an allegation may also raise safeguarding or regulatory questions. Identify any separate reporting obligations early and take advice on how these interact with the employment process.
4. Decide whether there is a disciplinary case to answer
Once the investigation is complete, consider whether the findings justify a formal disciplinary hearing. This is typically the decision of the chair or panel who would be managing a formal disciplinary process for the organisation.
Depending on the evidence, the appropriate next step might be that there is a case to answer at a hearing, further investigation or no formal action.
Where a hearing is required, it provides the opportunity to consider the evidence and the employee’s response before deciding the outcome.
A finding that there is a case to answer means the allegations warrant further consideration. It does not establish that the employee has committed gross misconduct.
5. Invite the employee to a disciplinary hearing
The written invitation should explain clearly:
- The specific allegations
- Why the conduct may amount to gross misconduct
- The possible outcomes, including dismissal without notice where relevant
- The evidence being considered
- The hearing arrangements
- The employee’s right to be accompanied.
It’s important that you provide the employee with the relevant evidence that would be relied upon at a hearing and allow reasonable time to prepare. You may need to consider if there is any evidence that needs to be redacted if it contains personal data of other individuals, or irrelevant information.
Avoid vague allegations such as “unacceptable behaviour” without explaining the incidents concerned.
A statutory companion can generally be a fellow worker, a certified trade union representative or a trade union official, but if you have a policy, check to see if there are additional rights over and above the statutory minimum.
You should also consider any reasonable adjustments for a disabled employee.
6. Hold a fair disciplinary hearing
The hearing should give the employee a meaningful opportunity to respond.
Explain the allegations and evidence, then allow them to present their account, ask questions, challenge information and identify relevant witnesses or documents.
Listen carefully to any explanation or mitigating circumstances.
If significant new information emerges, consider adjourning to investigate it before reaching a decision.
Keep an accurate record and take time after the hearing to consider the case. A prepared outcome letter handed over immediately can undermine confidence that the employee’s response received proper consideration.
7. Assess the evidence and circumstances
Before deciding whether gross misconduct has occurred, the decision-maker should ask:
- What do I conclude happened, and why?
- Which evidence supports that conclusion?
- Are there gaps or conflicting accounts?
- How serious was the conduct in context?
- What explanation has the employee provided?
- Were the relevant expectations clear?
- Have comparable cases been treated consistently?
A potentially fair reason for dismissal is only part of the assessment. Employers also need to act reasonably, investigate appropriately and listen to the employee’s views.
For example, where a serious procedure was breached, explore whether this involved deliberate disregard, a lack of understanding or an organisational failure in training or supervision. Those distinctions can essentially affect the decision.
8. Decide on an appropriate sanction
Gross misconduct does not make dismissal inevitable. Consider the seriousness of the findings alongside the employee’s explanation, previous record, length of service and any mitigating circumstances. Assess whether a lesser sanction would be appropriate and explain your reasoning.
Only someone with the necessary authority should make the dismissal decision.
Where summary dismissal is justified, the employee leaves without a notice period or notice pay. They remain entitled to outstanding wages, payment for accrued but untaken statutory holiday and other sums properly owed.
9. Confirm the decision in writing
The outcome letter should give the employee a clear explanation of the decision. Set out the allegations considered, the findings and the reasons for the sanction. Where dismissal is the outcome, explain why the conduct was sufficiently serious and why dismissal was appropriate.
Confirm the termination date, final pay arrangements and how to appeal.
Avoid relying on a general statement that “trust has broken down”. Explain the conduct and reasoning behind that conclusion so the employee can understand the decision.
10. Offer the right of appeal
An appeal gives the employee an opportunity to challenge the findings, sanction or fairness of the process, or to raise new evidence.
Explain how to appeal, who to contact and the applicable deadline.
The appeal should be considered impartially, with further investigation where needed, and its outcome confirmed in writing.
Where practicable, use someone who has not previously been involved.
Employees also have a statutory right to be accompanied at an appeal hearing.
A successful dismissal appeal will usually result in reinstatement, with continuity of employment preserved and lost pay addressed.
Can you dismiss someone for gross misconduct immediately?
Summary dismissal means that employment ends without notice once the dismissal decision has been reached. It does not remove the need to investigate and follow a fair procedure.
Even where an employee admits an incident, employers should consider their explanation, the surrounding circumstances and the appropriate sanction before deciding the outcome.
If immediate protective action is needed, consider suspension or another temporary arrangement whilst the concerns are investigated. This allows the organisation to respond to risk without deciding the disciplinary outcome prematurely.
What are the risks of getting a gross misconduct dismissal wrong?
An unfair or poorly managed dismissal can create legal, financial and organisational consequences.
Unfair dismissal
An employee who qualifies for ordinary unfair dismissal protection may challenge the reason for dismissal, the procedure or the reasonableness of the decision. As at November 2026, the qualifying period in Great Britain is generally two years. From 1 January 2027, it reduces to six months for dismissals with an effective termination date on or after that date.
The compensatory award cap is also being removed.
These changes do not apply to Northern Ireland, where the qualifying period remains generally one year.
Wrongful dismissal and discrimination
Wrongful dismissal concerns a breach of contract, commonly involving notice or notice pay. Employees do not need a minimum period of service to bring this type of claim. Short service also does not remove protection against discrimination or many automatically unfair reasons for dismissal, including whistleblowing and pregnancy-related reasons.
Failure to follow the Acas Code
Employment tribunals take the Acas Code into account in relevant cases. An employer’s unreasonable failure to follow it can increase compensation by up to 25%.
There are practical consequences too. A rushed process can damage staff confidence, unsettle beneficiaries and make future disciplinary decisions harder to manage consistently.
Common gross misconduct mistakes employers make
Some of the most avoidable problems arise when employers:
- Decide the outcome before investigating
- Suspend automatically without considering alternatives
- Assume gross misconduct permits dismissal on the spot
- Use vague or changing allegations
- Focus only on evidence supporting dismissal
- Withhold relevant evidence from the employee
- Overlook explanations or mitigating circumstances
- Treat comparable cases inconsistently
- Fail to explain why dismissal is appropriate
- Omit a meaningful appeal.
A useful question throughout the process is: Could someone unfamiliar with the case understand from our records how we reached this decision?
Clear evidence, balanced consideration and a reasoned outcome help demonstrate that the organisation has acted fairly.
When should you get HR advice?
Taking advice early can help managers identify the correct procedure, frame allegations clearly and avoid mistakes that become difficult to resolve later. This is particularly useful where allegations involve safeguarding, discrimination, senior leaders, conflicting witness accounts or concerns about impartiality
At Roots HR, we understand the pressures facing charities, social enterprises and other not-for-profit organisations. Our consultants provide practical advice and support with workplace investigations, disciplinary matters and complex people management situations.
Need support with a potential gross misconduct case?
Serious conduct concerns can be difficult to manage, especially when your organisation does not have in-house HR support. You may need to protect colleagues or beneficiaries whilst ensuring the employee has a fair opportunity to respond.
At Roots HR, we provide practical, people-focused advice to charities, social enterprises and other not-for-profit organisations on investigations, disciplinary hearings and dismissal decisions. We can help you assess the situation, follow an appropriate process and make informed decisions.
As part of our social impact commitment, we offer up to one hour of free HR consultancy to eligible social sector organisations. You can use your free hour to:
- Discuss an allegation and consider the appropriate next steps.
- Explore whether suspension or alternative arrangements may be appropriate.
- Review disciplinary policies, allegations and meeting letters.
- Consider investigation findings, possible outcomes and appeal arrangements.
Our consultants can support you by phone, email or Microsoft Teams. You can use the hour in one session or split it into up to four 15-minute conversations.
If you are managing a potential gross misconduct case, book your free HR consultation with Roots HR. We would be pleased to help.
Frequently asked questions
Can you dismiss someone immediately for gross misconduct?
Gross misconduct may justify dismissal without notice after a fair process. Employers should investigate the allegations and give the employee an opportunity to respond before deciding.
Do you have to investigate gross misconduct before dismissal?
Yes. The investigation should establish the relevant facts fairly. Its scope will depend on the allegations and available evidence.
Does gross misconduct mean no notice pay?
Where summary dismissal is justified, notice pay is not normally due. Outstanding wages, accrued statutory holiday pay and other sums owed still need to be paid.
Should an employee be suspended for gross misconduct?
Only where the circumstances justify it. Assess the risks and consider alternatives before deciding whether suspension is necessary.
What evidence do you need?
Relevant evidence may include documents, system records, witness accounts and the employee’s explanation. Investigators should consider information from both sides and explore conflicting evidence.
Can an employee appeal a gross misconduct dismissal?
Yes. Employers should offer an appeal so the employee can challenge the decision or process and raise relevant new evidence.
Do you need to give a warning first?
A prior warning is not always necessary for gross misconduct, even for a first offence. A fair process and consideration of the appropriate sanction remain essential.
Can you dismiss someone with less than two years’ service?
Yes, where justified. However, short service does not remove all legal protections. The ordinary unfair dismissal qualifying period in Great Britain also reduces to six months from 1 January 2027.